Thinking

Evidence for and against

Examine a thought like a detective: which facts support it and which contradict it.

Duration
10 min
Approach
CBT
Format
Working with thoughts
Difficulty
Easy

Helps withthoughts, anxiety, self-criticism, clarity, decisions

How to do it

  1. Write the thought as a statement, for example "I'll mess up the interview".
  2. Divide a sheet into two columns: "Facts for" and "Facts against".
  3. In the first column, put only facts that can be checked, without interpretations.
  4. In the second, put everything that doesn't fit the thought: past experience, other people's feedback, exceptions.
  5. Reread both columns and ask: what conclusion would seem fair to an outside observer?
  6. Write down the final, more balanced version.

Tips

  • "I feel this way" is not a fact but an experience; note it separately.
  • If the "against" column is empty, recall similar situations from the past year.

Do this practice with your AI companion

An exercise is easier to learn when someone suggests the next step and asks how it went. The Mentavita AI companion guides you step by step, picks an exercise for how you feel and helps you notice what works for you.

Disclaimer

Mentavita self-help exercises are for information only and do not replace an in-person consultation with a doctor, psychiatrist or licensed psychologist. If an exercise causes strong discomfort, stop. If you have severe symptoms or thoughts of self-harm or suicide, seek emergency help right away: 112.

More exercises: thinking

  • 01

    Three scenarios

    Eases fear of uncertainty and catastrophising: the worst, the best and the most likely outcome.

    5 min

  • 02

    Funny voice

    An ACT technique: an intrusive thought said in a silly voice loses its grip.

    2 min

  • 03

    Leaves on a stream

    An ACT exercise for stepping back from a stream of heavy thoughts.

    5 min

  • 04

    Worry tree

    A step-by-step guide to separating what you can influence from what is better let go.

    5 min

← All exercises